Proponentsofdifferentjazzstyleshavealwaysarguedthattheirpredecessor’smusicalstyledidnotincludeessentialcharacteristicsthatdefinejazzasjazz。Thus,1940’sswingwasbelittledbybeboppersofthe1950’swhowerethemselvesattackedbyfreejazzesofthe1960’s。Theneoboppersofthe1980’sand1990’sattackedalmosteverybodyelse。ThetitanicfigureofBlacksaxophonistJohnColtranehascomplicatedtheargumentsmadebyproponentsofstylesfrombebopthroughneobopbecauseinhisownmusicaljourneyhedrewfromallthosestyles。Hisinfluenceonalltypesofjazzwasimmeasurable。Attheheightofhispopularity,Coltranelargelyabandonedplayingbebop,thestylethathadbroughthimfame,toexploretheouterreachesofjazz。
Coltranehimselfprobablybelievedthattheonlyessentialcharacteristicofjazzwasimprovisation,theoneconstantinhisjourneyfrombeboptoopen-endedimprovisationsonmodal,Indian,andAfricanmelodies。Ontheotherhand,thisdoggedstudentandprodigioustechnician—whoinsistedonspendinghourseachdaypracticingscalesfromtheorybooks—wasneverabletojettisoncompletelytheinfluenceofbebop,withitsfastandelaboratechainsofnotesandornamentsonmelody。
TwostylisticcharacteristicsshapedthewayColtraneplayedthetenorsaxophone:hefavoredplayingfastrunsofnotesbuiltonamelodyanddependedonheavy,regularlyaccentedbeats。ThefirstledColtraneto“sheetsofsound”whereheracedfasterandfaster,pile-drivingnotesintoeachothertosuggeststackedharmonies。Thesecondmeantthathissenseofrhythmwasalmostasclosetorockastobebop。
ThreerecordingsillustrateColtrane’senergizingexplorations。RecordingKindofBluewithMilesDavis,Coltranefoundhimselfoutsidebop,exploringmodalmelodies。Hereheplayedsurging,lengthysolosbuiltlargelyaroundrepeatedmotifs—anorganizingprincipleunlikethatoffreejazzsaxophoneplayerOrnetteColeman,whomodulatedoralteredmelodiesinhissolos。OnGiantSteps,Coltranedebutedasleader,introducinghisowncompositions。Herethesheetsofsound,downbeataccents,repetitions,andgreatspeedarepartofeachsolo,andthevarietyoftheshapesofhisphrasesisunique。Coltrane’ssearchingexplorationsproducedsolidachievement。MyFavoriteThingswasanotherkindofwatershed。HereColtraneplayedthesopranosaxophone,aninstrumentseldomusedbyjazzmusicians。Musically,theresultswereastounding。Withthesoprano’spipingsound,ideasthathadsoundeddarkandbroodingacquiredafeelingofgiddyfantasy。
WhenColtranebeganrecordingfortheImpulse!Label,hewasstillsearching。Hismusicbecameraucous,physical。Hisinfluenceonrockerswasenormous,includingJimiHendrix,therockguitarist,who,followingColtrane,raisedtheextendedguitarsolousingrepeatedmotifstoakindofrockartform。